Polish Court Ruling: EU Treaty Subordinate to Constitution
Judge Sochanski's Interpretation
In a groundbreaking ruling on Thursday, Judge Bartlomiej Sochanski of Poland declared that the European Union (EU) Treaty is subordinate to the Polish Constitution. This ruling has sparked a significant debate over the relationship between EU law and national constitutions.
Consequences of the Ruling
Sochanski's ruling has far-reaching implications for the legal framework of the EU. It suggests that member states may have the authority to override EU laws if they conflict with their national constitutions.
"With the best will to interpret the constitution, it is impossible to find in it the powers of the EU," Sochanski stated in his verdict.
EU Response
The EU has expressed concern over the ruling, arguing that it undermines the principle of supremacy of EU law. Supremacy means that EU laws take precedence over national laws in areas where the EU has exclusive competence. The EU Commission is currently considering legal action against Poland over the matter.
Implications for Poland
The ruling is a significant victory for the Polish government, which has been critical of EU law. It could potentially lead to a reduction in Poland's involvement in EU affairs or even a potential exit from the union.
However, it is important to note that the ruling is specific to Poland and does not necessarily apply to other EU member states. Each member state has its own constitutional framework and may interpret the relationship with EU law differently.
Comments